Why the box price is the least useful number
Two wipes at the same price per box are rarely the same price per square metre, and almost never the same cost per clean square metre. Boxes hold different counts, wipes come in different sizes, and one construction may need two passes where another needs one.
Procurement tends to compare the line that is easiest to see: the carton price. The number that reaches the cost of goods is two transformations away from it.
The formula
Cost per square metre is the carton price divided by the wipes in the carton, divided again by the area of one wipe in square metres.
- Convert the wipe size to metres first: 25 × 35 cm is 0.25 × 0.35 = 0.0875 m².
- Divide the carton price by the wipe count to get cost per wipe.
- Divide cost per wipe by the area to get cost per m².
Then multiply by the number of passes the surface actually needs. That product — not the carton price — is what you compare.
A worked comparison
Two universal cloths, both quoted in the same week:
- Cloth A. 25 × 35 cm, 500 per carton, $18.00. Cost per wipe: $0.036. Area: 0.0875 m². Cost per m²: $0.41.
- Cloth B. 30 × 40 cm, 300 per carton, $15.00. Cost per wipe: $0.050. Area: 0.12 m². Cost per m²: $0.42.
On paper they are within two cents. On the line they are not. Cloth A is thinner and needs two passes to lift the soil on a coolant-heavy panel; Cloth B clears it in one.
- Cloth A: $0.41 × 2 passes = $0.82 per clean m².
- Cloth B: $0.42 × 1 pass = $0.42 per clean m².
Add labour and the gap widens. At an loaded rate of $30 per hour, a 30-second pass costs $0.25. Cloth A spends $0.50 of labour per cleaned m²; Cloth B spends $0.25. Total cost per clean square metre: $1.32 against $0.67.
The costs nobody puts in the comparison
Rework. A wipe that leaves a fiber trail or a residue film sends the part back through cleaning or, worse, through inspection again. One rejected panel can exceed the annual saving on the cloth.
Defect rate. Scratches from a too-firm cloth and haze from a residue film both appear downstream, where the cost of detection is highest.
Disposal and storage. A bulkier carton costs more to store and to move. A heavier GSM cloth carries more weight per clean square metre than the price suggests.
Inventory complexity. Five sizes for five tasks looks efficient on a price list and expensive in the warehouse. Standardising to two formats often beats a 6% unit-price saving.
The materials guide explains which constructions need a second pass and why — absorbency rate and hand feel matter more than GSM here.
Run it on your own line
- Fix the surface, the soil and the solvent. A cost comparison across different soils is not a comparison.
- Count passes to a defined acceptance criterion, not to “looks clean”.
- Weigh the wipes. Cost per kilogram explains why a heavier cloth at the same carton price is not cheaper.
- Include labour: passes × seconds per pass × loaded hourly rate.
- Add the defect cost you can actually measure, even if it is an estimate from the last quarter.
For a critical surface, add the qualification cost once: a trial, a data package, a line trial. It is a one-off, but it belongs in the first-year number.
Questions that change the quote
Ask each supplier for the wipe count per carton, the measured size after folding, the GSM with tolerance, and the recommended passes for your soil. Then ask what happens to the price at the volume your passes actually imply — not the volume in the original enquiry. A cloth that needs half the wipes is worth a higher unit price.
If you want the comparison run on your own soil, request samples of two formats and send the panel description; the sales team will quote against the pass count rather than the carton.
Bottom line. Run the calculation on your own soil before the tender. If you want a second pair of eyes on the numbers, send the panel description and we will quote against the pass count rather than the carton.
Frequently asked questions
Is a higher GSM always more expensive per square metre?
Usually, because you are buying more fiber per square metre. But GSM is not the only cost driver: a lighter, better-bonded cloth can cost more per kilogram and still be cheaper per clean square metre if it needs fewer passes.
Should I compare cost per wipe instead?
Only when the wipes are the same size and the same construction. Otherwise cost per wipe hides the area difference, which is exactly what the carton price hides.
Where does the edge fit into the calculation?
A sealed edge costs more per wipe and reduces fiber shedding, which reduces rework on critical surfaces. On a general workshop floor the sealed edge rarely pays back; in an ISO Class 5 zone it usually does. The edge guide sets out the trade.
Should disposal be included in the calculation?
Yes, if the wipes are hazardous after use. Oil-soaked cloths often cost more to dispose of than to buy, which can reverse the ranking of two formats.
How does a sealed edge change the maths?
It raises the cost per wipe and can remove rework on a critical surface. Add the defect cost you actually measure; on a general workshop floor the sealed edge rarely pays back.
